Three-Member LCMS Panel To Try Death of God Case: Werning vs. Cascione

By: Rev. Jack Cascione


 

A three-member panel will now be assembled to hear the case Doctor Waldo Werning continues to file in Dispute Resolution against me, Rev. Jack Cascione.  Both Werning and Cascione have the option of removing three of nine names they received in the mail, from the panel.

 

How does claiming that God died in Christ on Good Friday become a matter of Dispute Resolution in the Missouri Synod?  The answer is: by pointing out that there are heretics in the LCMS who reject this doctrine and naming the heretics in public.

 

While some LCMS Pastors will be proclaiming this coming Holy Week 2004 that God died in Christ on Good Friday, a corrupt administration in the Synodical Head Quarters supports efforts to stop this teaching in the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod.

 

President Gerald Kieschnick is supposed to be the chief doctrinal officer in the LCMS, but he will not answer letters addressed to him asking about who died on the Cross.

 

Reclaim News will pay $100.00 to any LCMS approved Mission , in behalf of the person who can get President Gerald Kieschnick to answer the following question:

 

“Did the entire, whole, complete God die in Christ on Good Friday?”

 

Kieschnick’s email address is Gerald.Kieschnick@lcms.org

 

Kieschnick can also be reached by mail at: 1333 S. Kirkwood Road , St. Louis , MO 63122-7295

 

To receive the 100 dollars, Kieschnick’s answer must be a direct “yes” or “no” from President Kieschnick himself.  Kieschnick had no trouble telling the entire Synod that he agreed with Atlantic District President, David Benke, praying with Moslems in Yankee Stadium before Dr. Wallace Schulz, and then the three-member panel, heard the case.

 

Werning claims that the entire, whole, complete God did not die in Christ on Good Friday.  He also claims that Christians experience God in a three-fold manner; God has three manners of being; God has three levels of reality; three ways of revealing Himself; and three forms of speaking to us.  I published that Werning teaches false doctrine on all of these issues, in his book “Health and Healing for the LCMS.”  Werning claims that he speaks the truth about God and I am breaking the Eighth Commandment.

 

If I’m not telling the truth about Christ, then I’m breaking a lot more than the Eighth Commandment. The readers are invited to read Dr. Edward Koehler’s explanation of this doctrine below, and decide for themselves.

 

The following question and answer is from the 1943 LCMS Catechism and the explanation about the two natures of Christ is from pages 141-142 of Koehler’s “Annotated Catechism.”

 

128 Question: What two natures, then, are united in Christ?

 

Answer: The divine and the human natures are united in Christ, both natures together forming one undivided and indivisible person (personal union).

 

1. As body and soul are united so as to make one human being, so the divine and the human nature are in Christ so closely and intimately united as to make one undivided and indivisible person, one Christ. From Isaiah 9:6 we learn that the promised Messiah is to be born as a human child, yet at the same time He is called "the mighty God, the everlasting Father ".  In Matt. 16:13 Jesus calls Himself the "Son of Man", and in v.16 He accepts as true Peter's answer that He is "the Son of the living God".  So He is man and God in one person, the God-man. (Read the Athanasian Creed).

 

2. The divine nature was not changed into a human nature, and the human nature was not changed into the divine nature, but though intimately united, each nature is distinct and complete in itself.  If either nature had been changed into the other, the text “In Him dwelleth all the fullness of the God head bodily” (Col. 2:9) would not be true.  As the soul dwells in the body, so "the fullness of the Godhead" dwelled in this particular human nature of Jesus.

 

3. The divine nature existed from eternity as the Second Person of the Godhead, but in the fullness of time the Son of God was born of a woman (Gal. 4:4-5), the Word was made flesh (John 1:14), assumed, took on, a human nature.  This happened at the conception of Christ (Luke 1:35 ), and since then the two natures have never separated, not even when Jesus died on the cross.

 

4. Thus we have here a great mystery, which human reason cannot fathom, that in Jesus God was manifest in the flesh (1 Tim 3:16).  Because the fullness of the Godhead had made this human nature its dwelling place (Col. 2:9), the disciples beheld in Jesus, when He performed miracles (John 2:11 ), and on the mount of transfiguration (Matt. 17:2) "the glory as of the only-begotten of the Father" (John 1:14 ).  This union of the two natures in one person is called the Personal Union.  Because of this personal union of the two natures each nature participates in the attributes and works of the other nature.  Thus the divine nature is, of itself, omnipotent, omnipresent, omniscient, etc., but when it took on the human nature, this nature also became omnipotent (Matt. 28:18), omnipresent (Matt. 28:20), omniscient (John 21:17 ).  Again, the human nature has a body, has blood, can be crucified and killed, but as this particular human nature belonged to the Son of God, we speak of God's body and blood (314; Acts 20:28), and that the Son of God was killed and crucified (Acts 3:15) in His human nature. When Christ performed miracles, the divine nature acted through the human nature. And in the work of redemption both natures cooperated.  Therefore Christ is our Savior not only in the human or only in the divine nature, but in both natures. This is called the Communication of Attributes.

 2004